A traditional oven is trusted and guaranteed, but what if you don’t have access to one? An electric turkey roaster will save the day whether you’re preparing Thanksgiving dinner or hosting some of your friends for a cozy gathering. In this article, we’ll list some of the best electric turkey roaster reviews to help you find the right one.
We’ll explain how to choose the best and use it to prepare a delicious meal for your loved ones.
Electric roasters are versatile appliances that will help you cook several recipes. Even a large turkey won’t seem that challenging when you have the right appliance available. So let’s dig in.
Electric Turkey Roaster Reviews
A turkey takes a few hours to cook perfectly, and an electric roaster will free up space in your main oven, so you can prepare other delicious dishes until your turkey is ready to be served. This way, you’ll also guarantee that your feast will be warm and inviting, as all the dishes are cooking at the same time.
Because it’s so versatile, your electric turkey roaster will be used all year long, and not just during the holiday season. Here are our top picks.
1. Stamo 24 Quart Electric Roaster Oven
This 1450-watt electric roaster is the perfect choice for busy households as it can be used to slow-cook, bake, and roast various dishes. It comes with a removable steel rack to help you carry your dish when it’s done. It measures 24 X 17 X 10 inches, so it’s bigger than most models on our list.
With a 24-quart capacity, this roaster will fit a 28-pound turkey with no issues. It features a self-basting lid to circulate the warm air and keep your food moist and juicy. The interior pan is removable for easy cleaning. Just fill it with soapy water, and your roaster will be ready for the next dish. The lid is dishwasher safe and allows you to see your food while it’s cooking.
Carrying larger dishes will be easier thanks to the lift-out rack. There’s a full temperature range from 150 to 450 degrees Fahrenheit to help you prepare multiple dishes.
This roaster will stay stable on the countertop for maximum safety, thanks to the anti-skid rubber feet. The cord can be conveniently stored to keep your kitchen mess-free.
You can also activate the warming function to keep your food at the ideal serving temperature. The handles stay cold while you’re preparing your food for maximum safety. It’s recommended to wipe it clean before the first use because it smokes.
What We Like
- Larger capacity for a bigger turkey.
- Removable interior pan for easy cleanup.
- Lid is transparent and dishwasher safe.
- Warming function to keep your food at the ideal serving temperature.
- Cold handles.
- Anti-skid rubber feet to keep it stable.
What We Don’t Like
- It smokes when used for the first time.
2. NESCO ITR-01 Digital Infrared Upright Turkey Roaster
With a non-conventional design, this 1420-watt roaster keeps your turkey upright to cook evenly by allowing the warm air to circulate for the best results. It’s designed to cook an 18-pound turkey in less than 2 hours.
It’s a stainless-steel roaster that doesn’t allow the food particles to stick for effortless cleaning. You can use it for cooking turkey, chicken, and even meat dishes to impress your family and guests. It measures 18.7 X 18.78 X 17.95 inches.
The digital controls increase the temperature from 275 to 500 degrees Fahrenheit for a perfectly cooked turkey. The centered infrared heating element cooks your turkey from the inside out and guarantees that even the interior part will be cooked to perfection. It keeps your turkey moist while browning the outer part to impress everyone with your culinary skills.
You’ll be able to view your turkey while it’s cooking because the lid has a transparent part. As a result, you won’t have to open the cover to check on your food, as this will allow the heat to escape and can jeopardize the final result. This roaster features a cooking stand and a drip tray for easy cleanup. The easy-grip side handles allow you to carry this roaster easily.
After preparing your food, you won’t struggle to clean this roaster because the cooking stand is dishwasher safe. However, this roaster doesn’t allow you to do other things like simmering, baking, and boiling, so it’s less versatile than other options. Moreover, the digital controls allow you to choose between two temperature settings, high and low, as it’s designed to cook a turkey in the first place.
What We Like
- Specifically designed to cook turkeys in less time.
- Centered infrared heating element to cook your turkey from the inside out.
- Keeps the turkey moist while the outer part browns evenly.
- Transparent lid to allow you to view the turkey while it’s cooking without allowing the heat to escape.
- A cooking stand and drip tray for easy cleanup.
What We Don’t Like
- Features only two heat settings.
- Less versatile than other roasters.
3. Hamilton Beach 28 lb. 22-Quart Roaster
A 28-pound turkey will fit perfectly into this roaster. With a 22-quart capacity and the convenience of a conventional oven, this will be the perfect addition to your kitchen, regardless of your culinary skills. It measures 24 X 17.5 X 10.5 inches to accommodate bigger items.
Using this 1420-watt roaster, you’ll be able to bake or roast various dishes, as the temperature can be adjusted between 150 to 450 degrees Fahrenheit. This roaster can fit a 9 by 13-inch baking pan and keeps your dishes warm for about 1 hour until the rest of your recipes are cooked. The lid adds more height to fit a bigger turkey.
The removable rack allows you to remove bigger items easily. You can even carry the roaster to the dinner table.
After your dish is ready, cleanup is easy, thanks to the stainless-steel construction. However, it lacks a temperature light indicator.
What We Like
- Stainless-steel roaster with a lid to add more height.
- Can be used for roasting and baking.
- Removable racks to transfer your dishes to the dining table.
- Keeps food warm.
- Easy cleanup.
What We Don’t Like
- Doesn’t have a light indicator.
4. EaZy BrandZ EZO-3016B oberdome plus Countertop Electric Roaster
This 1150-watt roaster features a unique design that shortens the cooking time for the best result. The heating element is located in the lid to encapsulate the food, allowing the warm air to circulate evenly, cooking your turkey to perfection and 51% faster than a conventional oven. It measures 21.58 X 17.32 X 12 inches.
It’s big enough to fit a 22-pound turkey, two chickens, or a 12-inch pizza. It can be used for baking, simmering, and boiling several recipes, so it’s a versatile addition to your cooking arsenal.
Unlike other models, this one preheats in about 6 minutes, so it’s an excellent choice for a busy household or someone who is in a hurry. It weighs less than other models, so it’s a portable choice for camping adventures and road trips.
The enamel-coated ceramic surface prevents food from sticking and makes it easier to clean. The rack can be used in two positions for more cooking flexibility. The stainless-steel bottom acts as a serving tray and even features a spout for pouring the drippings.
You can adjust the temperature between 250 and 450 degrees Fahrenheit. But since it heats up too fast, you can easily burn your turkey if you’re not careful.
What We Like
- Heating element is located in the lid for even cooking results.
- Reduces the cooking time.
- Can be used for various cooking options.
- Enamel-coated ceramic surface is easy to clean.
- The rack can be used in two positions.
What We Don’t Like
- Can burn the food if you’re not careful.
5. BELLA 24-Pound Turkey Roaster
This 1450-watt electric roaster combines a classical design with digital technology to cook your food evenly. It’s big enough with a 17-quart capacity to fit a 24-pound turkey and features a digital temperature control from 150 to 450 degrees Fahrenheit with a power indicator.
It features a removable cooking pan and wire rack for easy cleaning. Although it smokes for a few minutes the first time you use it, this won’t be an issue if you wipe it clean and let it smoke for several minutes. It measures 23.82 X 17.52 X 8.66 inches.
Because it’s made of stainless steel, food particles won’t get stuck. Compared to other electric roasters, this one will help cook your turkey fast, guaranteeing that the crust will be brown and crispy while the interior stays juicy. The lid allows the warm air to circulate to cook a big turkey evenly.
None of the parts is dishwasher safe and will need more effort to have them cleaned. The handles stay to touch, but the sides are prone to dents if you’re not careful while handling this electric roaster.
What We Like
- Electric turkey roaster with a large capacity.
- Removable cooking pan and wire rack.
- Stainless steel interior.
- Cool to touch handles.
- Keeps your turkey moist and juicy.
What We Don’t Like
- It smokes when used for the first time.
- Not dishwasher safe and takes time to be appropriately cleaned.
6. Oster Roaster Oven with Self-Basting Lid
Cooking a 26-pound turkey won’t be a problem because this 22-quart roaster will make your job easier. It also bakes, slow-cooks, and keeps your dishes warm. You can also use it to simmer the gravy without messing up your stovetop. It measures 23.3 X 15.6 X 11.8 inches.
The temperature control ranges from 150 to 450 degrees Fahrenheit, so it can be used to cook multiple dishes. The lid circulates the hot air to cook your turkey evenly.
Unlike other models, this 1450-watt roaster retains the heat to cook multiple recipes to perfection. It also browns the skin of your turkey, so everyone will be impressed with your culinary skills.
Thanks to the non-stick cooking pan, you’ll be able to clean this roaster easily. However, the rim is sharp and unfinished, so it might hurt you while you’re cooking your food. The handles stay cold while you’re using the roaster, but the body gets too hot, so you need to be careful while using it.
What We Like
- Big enough to accommodate a bigger turkey.
- Can be used for baking, roasting, and slow-cooking.
- Lid circulates the hot air to keep the turkey moist.
- Easy to clean.
- Handles stay cool.
What We Don’t Like
- The rim isn’t finished.
- The outer surface of the roaster becomes too hot.
7. NESCO 4818-12 18-Quart Classic Roaster Oven with Porcelain Cookwell
This roaster does all the functions of a conventional oven, except broiling. It’s the perfect addition to your kitchen with a traditional porcelain finish and has a capacity of 18 quarts, allowing you to prepare multiple dishes with no issues.
You can use it to roast, stew, bake, and even boil or slow-cook your food. Everything from delicious soup to a 22-pound turkey can be easily prepared in this 1420-watt roaster.
The roaster has full-range temperature control from 200 to 450 degrees Fahrenheit and comes with a porcelain-coated cook well to prevent the food from sticking. The porcelain resists corrosion and scratches for maximum safety. It measures 24.75 X 16.75 X 9 inches.
It features a heating element to circulate the warm air, keeping your turkey moist and juicy. The roaster features a removable steel rack with handles to help you remove and insert hot food.
There are several colors available, so you’ll be able to pick one that matches the rest of your kitchen appliances. The porcelain cook well isn’t as easy to clean as stainless steel and needs more soak time, but it still cooks your food to perfection.
What We Like
- Versatile roaster that does everything a traditional oven can do.
- Porcelain cook well prevents the food from sticking.
- Resists corrosion and scratches.
- Removable steel rack to remove hot food.
What We Don’t Like
- The porcelain cook well needs more soak time to be cleaned.
8. Sunvivi 22QT Electric Roaster Oven
This electric roaster won’t let you down, thanks to its 22-quart capacity. In addition to being able to roast, bake, slow-cook, and boil your food, you’ll be able to activate the keep warm feature. This will preserve the temperature until your food is ready to be served and the rest of the dishes are finished.
The temperature control ranges from 150 to 450 degrees Fahrenheit, in addition to a defrost temperature setting to get your food ready before a feast. It measures 25.5 X 17.4 X 10.4 inches.
The removable steel grill and pan allow for handling. Although the roaster’s temperature increases to cook your food evenly, the handles stay cool to touch for maximum protection. The non-stick coating surface makes it quite easy to clean using soapy water.
Don’t worry about your food drying or not cooking because the lid circulates the warm air to keep your food moist. A turkey will be perfectly cooked with a delicious brown crust, and the meat will feel juicy. The 1450-watt roaster is big enough to accommodate a 26 or 28-pound turkey that takes between 3 and 4 hours until it’s ready.
When it’s time for preparing your Thanksgiving feast, your oven will be free to prepare the rest of your signature dishes. However, smoking is a big issue, so you’ll have to switch it on several times and rinse the interior until it stops smoking.
What We Like
- Big-capacity electric roaster.
- A warming feature and defrosting temperature.
- Cooks the food evenly.
- Non-stick coating for easy cleaning.
- Removable steel pan.
What We Don’t Like
- Smokes during the first few uses.
9. Proctor Silex 32191 Roaster Oven
This 1440-watt electric roaster helps you cook multiple dishes as you can roast, bake, and boil different recipes while saving space in the oven. The 18-quart capacity will help you cook a 24-pound turkey with no issues. It measures 23.75 X 17.25 X 9.6 inches.
An 18-pound unstuffed turkey can be cooked in about two and half hours while you have time to cook a delicious side dish in your oven. You can even use it to simmer your gravy or warm up the soup until your feast is ready.
This versatile roaster also fits a 9 by 5-inch pan for baking. The domed lid adds an extra height for bigger items, so you won’t feel limited by its design.
Thanks to its attractive design, this roaster can be taken from the kitchen to the buffet for easy serving. You can also use it to keep dishes warm until all the other dishes are ready.
The easy lift-out rack allows you to remove larger items with no issues. The removable pan features an enamel coating that covers the steel body for effortless cleaning.
However, this roaster doesn’t brown the meat evenly. You need to be extra careful while using this roaster because it’s not properly insulated and can burn your hands if you accidentally touch it.
What We Like
- Versatile roaster for multiple cooking functions.
- Big capacity and a domed lid to add extra height for larger items.
- Attractive design that allows you to serve food.
- Easy lift-out rack to remove larger items.
- Easy cleaning.
What We Don’t Like
- Doesn’t brown the meat properly.
- The outside of the roaster gets too hot while you’re cooking your food.
What are the Benefits of Buying an Electric Turkey Roaster?
A traditional oven will help you cook a turkey to perfection, but an electric roaster can do a lot more. This compact yet practical appliance guarantees that a turkey will be perfectly cooked in its delicious juices for the best results. It also opens the door to more cooking options, especially when you’re busy preparing for an event. Here are some of the benefits of buying this appliance.
- An electric roaster is a versatile and practical cooking appliance that you can use to cook a turkey easily, even if you’re not an experienced chef or have a traditional oven. It can also be used for cooking fish, chicken, meat, as well as baking dishes, simmering sauce, and boiling soup before your feast.
- It doubles your cooking space. If you already have a conventional oven, a roaster will be used to cook your turkey for hours, while you can use your oven to prepare other dishes.
- Due to its size and design, an electric roaster will save the energy needed to cook a big turkey. Your turkey will be cooked in less time, which makes it an excellent choice for busy people.
- After using the roaster, it will be easy to store and clean. It’s a suitable choice for a smaller kitchen.
- An electric roaster saves space in a smaller kitchen and still allows you to cook larger items.
- While using your oven for cooking other dishes, the roaster will keep your food warm until it’s serving time.
- A roaster that features a removable rack can also be used for serving food. The stylish design and the easy-to-lift rack will allow you to transfer larger items to the dinner table with no issues.
How to Use an Electric Turkey Roaster
Before you start using it, there are a few tips that can help you prepare the most delicious dishes using your roaster.
- When you’re using the roaster for the first time, wipe it clean and add a little water, then switch it on to let it smoke. It’s normal for the electric roaster to smoke when it’s used for the first time, and this step will guarantee that any residue or chemicals won’t get in touch with your food.
- Preheat the roaster for the best results. This will guarantee that all the parts of your turkey will start cooking at the same time. Preheating the roaster is also essential if you’re using it for other dishes like baked recipes.
- The lid allows for basting your turkey for a better taste. You shouldn’t open the cover as this will allow the heat to escape and affect the result.
- Use the right temperature while cooking your turkey or any other dish. A roaster heats better and faster than a conventional oven, so you don’t want to increase the temperature or extend the cooking time, as this might burn your turkey.
- Take out the roasting pan for easy cleaning. A roaster with a non-stick surface will be easier and faster to clean. In most cases, soaking the parts in soapy water will be enough unless the parts are dishwasher safe.
How to Choose the Best Electric Turkey Roaster
Since there are lots of models available, finding the best electric turkey roaster can be a little tricky. Here are a few features to consider before choosing an electric roaster.
Capacity
A smaller roaster will fit a smaller turkey or a big chicken, but it will be a suitable choice for a smaller family. If you have a tiny kitchen, you can still maximize your cooking space by investing in the right roaster.
Think about the size of the items that you usually cook. You can buy a roaster that fits a 12-pound turkey to feed up to 8 people or choose a bigger model that fits a 22-pound turkey. This will be more suitable for bigger gatherings as it can feed more than 16 people. However, you need to think about the space you have in your kitchen to set up and store this roaster after use.
Energy Consumption
A roaster with a higher wattage heats faster. It will also retain the temperature throughout the cooking process for the best results.
Choosing a roaster with a higher wattage is a must if you’re cooking a bigger turkey. However, it will use more energy.
Lid
A domed lid will add more height to your roaster. As a result, it will be able to fit a bigger turkey with no issues.
You can also choose a lid with a transparent top that allows you to watch your turkey while it’s cooking. As a result, you won’t have to open the lid to trap the heat for even cooking.
Surface
Roasters come in various finishes, so you can pick a stainless-steel model that allows for even cooking and easy cleaning. Ceramic-coated surfaces are also non-stick.
Make sure that you wipe the roaster to remove all the drippings and empty the dripping tray if you have one. Some parts are not dishwasher safe, so you can soak them in soapy water.
Wrap Up
Cooking a turkey will be easy if you have the best electric turkey roaster. We chose the Stamo 24 Quart Electric Roaster Oven as our top choice because it’s big enough to accommodate a 28-pound turkey with no issues. The lid adds extra height to your roaster, and the handles stay cool to touch.
If you’re looking for a smaller model, you can check out the NESCO ITR-01 Digital Infrared Upright Turkey Roaster. It fits an 18-pound turkey, allowing you to prepare the best dishes for a family gathering or friendly dinner.